JOIN VNN COLUMNIST TEAM | SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER
VETERANS NEWS NOW ON : FACEBOOK | TWITTER | FORUM
|

Why Obama’s Israel Trip Is One Big Mistake

Netanyahu insults the president, backed Romney, and hasn’t moved the peace process. No White House should reward behavior like that, not even from an ally.

 

By

Slate

 

Iran is accelerating its nuclear program. Syria’s gruesome civil war is beginning to bleed across its borders. Two years after Hosni Mubarak’s ouster, Egypt’s political transition is, at best, dicey. And yet according to deputy national security adviser Ben Rhodes, “more important” than all of that “in some respects” is that President Obama take this opportunity to “speak directly to the Israeli people.’’

I get the logic of whoever dreamed up the president’s trip to Israel this week: Send Obama to reassure the Israelis he’s got their back on Iran. Demonstrate he doesn’t prefer the Arabs—an impression left in his first term when he visited Cairo but didn’t stop by Tel Aviv. Pay his respects at the graves of Israel’s fallen and acknowledge the historical artifacts that show Jews’ ties to the land. Let them know he really admires their technological prowess. Then maybe Israelis will feel more inclined to make peace with the Palestinians knowing the relationship with their most important ally is solid.

But this trip—the timing and the script—makes no sense. And even more than simply being a big waste of Obama’s time at a moment when he has little time to waste, it’s burning crucial American political capital that ought to be reserved for moments that truly warrant it.

The White House says the president is going to hear out what the newly appointed Israeli government has planned. Here’s a quick preview: Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon wants to bomb Iran and Housing Minister Uri Ariel wants to build new settlements. If Obama wants to talk about drafting ultra-Orthodox Jews into the Israel Defense Forces or the price of apartments in Tel Aviv, he’ll find an audience. Those relatively marginal issues are what dominated Israel’s recent election, not the future with the Palestinians.

Three years ago, Vice President Joe Biden went to Israel tasked with a similar mission—reassure Israelis that Obama loves them. Biden hit all the right notes, saying that the bond between Israel and the United States was “unshakeable” and “unbreakable” so many times that we reporters who covered that trip started keeping a running tally. Then as the vice-presidential motorcade was leaving the Yad Vashem Holocaust museum, news that Israel’s Interior Ministry had authorized 1,600 housing units in East Jerusalem destroyed what should have been a pure celebration of American-Israeli ties. Biden returned to his hotel to consult with the White House on what to say, leaving Netanyahu waiting awkwardly at his residence for an hour and a half for dinner. When Biden arrived, he issued an unprecedented rebuke that embarrassed the Israeli prime minister as they sat down to eat.

American-Israeli ties remained sour. Two months after Biden’s visit, Obama refused to hold a photo op with Netanyahu when he visited the White House. The next year, when the president agreed to share the stage with Israel’s prime minister, Netanyahu lectured him before the cameras in the Oval Office on why Obama’s (hardly original) idea that the 1967 borders could be a baseline for peace negotiations with the Palestinians was bunk. In 2012, Netanyahu—frustrated that he couldn’t goad Obama into saying when the U.S. would bomb Iran—publicly suggested the president had no “moral right” to stop Israel from taking action itself. All the while, Netanyahu, over the past few years, did nothing to further peace with the Palestinians. He floated via surrogates that he thought Obama was naïve on the Middle East. And he left the strong impression last year that he was rooting for Mitt Romney to win the U.S. presidential election.

In spite of all this, the president is headed to Tel Aviv. The anti-Obama peace-process skeptics can’t help but gloat. As Barry Rubin, a conservative, pro-Israel American pundit put it on his Facebook page: “I think we have just won a huge victory … Obama has admitted defeat on trying to bully, manipulate, or pressure Israel.”

The White House doesn’t want this trip to be about Netanyahu or his new government. That’s why Obama will address Israeli college students in a convention hall rather than speak to politicians in the Knesset. But when it comes to how this trip will be perceived in Israel, it will be all about Netanyahu and his political fortunes. Netanyahu will be seen as the victor in his battle with Obama, rewarded not only for defying—or standing strongly against, depending on one’s political perspective—an American president. And Netanyahu will learn one powerful lesson from Obama’s visit: I don’t have to do anything on the Palestinian issue. I can continue to expand settlements, focus solely on Iran, and insult the U.S. president, and he will still come and thank me with a two-day dog-and-pony show.

It’s clear why the White House wants to avoid the thorny Israeli-Palestinian disputes of Jerusalem, settlements, and refugees. Past presidents have expended enormous time and energy on the matter and failed miserably. The last time Obama tried to articulate some guiding principles on borders, he got shouted down by Bibi. The United States “will always continue to be engaged in this process in terms of trying to move it forward,’’ Rhodes told reporters in a pretrip briefing that illustrated just how radically Obama has scaled back his ambitions since September 2010, when he said he thought peace could be achieved within a year.

So why is Obama going? Is it really an attempt at “repairing relations with America’s primary Middle East ally” as the Washington Post’s Scott Wilson wrote? Or as Jeffrey Goldberg wrote in a column for Bloomberg, to reintroduce himself to Israelis and convey to them that he understands their situation? Perhaps. But if it is, then this is truly a waste of time. Just as Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel—whose nomination was held up by those who worried he wasn’t pro-Israel enough—wasn’t running for Israeli defense minister, Obama isn’t running for Israeli office (or any office for that matter). And anyone who knows Israelis and their current mindset on the Palestinians (Palestinians, who?) knows that a little ego stroking isn’t going to get that population behind a peace deal.

That doesn’t mean the trip couldn’t do some good. While the president is there ostensibly repairing the relationship with Israelis who’ve felt jilted, Obama may be sending an important signal to Tehran. The message: Just because I can’t stand Bibi doesn’t mean I won’t stand with him in preventing you from getting a nuclear weapon.

Since Obama is making the 12-hour flight, there’s one important thing he can accomplish if he wants to achieve something beyond simply making Israelis feel good. When he delivers his speech in Jerusalem on Thursday, he can remind Israelis that if they want their nation to be a nation like all others—one with internationally accepted borders, no longer targeted by divestment campaigns, and not facing a possible third Intifada—they need to stop saying they have no partner and make peace with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas before it is too late. And if they can do that, he looks forward to coming back a second time as president—when they have a peace deal to sign.


Janine Zacharia, formerly the Jerusalem bureau chief of the Washington Post, is the Carlos Kelly McClatchy visiting lecturer at Stanford University.

Short URL: http://www.veteransnewsnow.com/?p=222649

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VNN or any other VNN authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors or partners. Notices

Posted by on Mar 20 2013, With 0 Reads, Filed under Americas, Asia, Bahrain, Causes, China, Editors' Picks, Egypt, Europe, Global, Iran, Israel, Life, Middle East, Oceana, Oman, Palestine, Peace, Syria, United Kingdom, Yemen. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
Get Your Loan Now
Apply for VA Loan Now
Education
Get Your Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now

COMMENTS

To post a comment, you must login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with our site and post your comment.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Legal Notice


Comments Closed

2 Comments for “Why Obama’s Israel Trip Is One Big Mistake”

  1. Regardless of the few positives that the artlicle mentions as possible from this trip, it is only Wednesday and Obama has aready grovelled to the orchestrated tune of the Israelis

    And there is a further speech to come? Wow. How much lower can he get. The same old rhetoric, we’ve heard it all before in little Israel (the USA) through the offices of the AIPAC master of ceremonies, Biden. Now that was a performance scripted in Hollywood as everything about this current visit is as well.

    We’ll see nothing come out of this but the same old pathetic drivel. Ramallah will be a joke.

    We have seen 66 UN resolutions stop per courtesy of the US veto any peace progress in this part of the world. I have said in other places, ad nauseum, the Palestinians are becoming less relevant to the US than ever before because by shrewdness and cunning, Israeli traits, the Israelis have made full use of the discrepancies in the character of Americans, a lack of guts to do the things that need to be done under the corrupt regimes of the US Congress and the Senate and weak presidents. Certainly, the US can decalre war against Iraq, defenceless and compliantly on their bellies, use superior weaponry at 25,000 feet in the sky against 600,000 defencless Laotians and Cambodians but it cannot legislate against disloyalty in their own country and bring to bear the pressure needed to have some future as Americans, not Israeli stooges, because that is what they have now become. No other word for it.

    This visit will just confirm it, once again. Going through the motions and licking the boots of a cruel and inhumane country, a pariah state, the modern day Third Reich.

    Well done, America. You never disappoint, always predictable.

    • Israel is of no strategic interest to the US PERIOD. Unless Americans assume its a given that the Islamic world must be a foe, attachment to Israel is only a liability. There you have their Prez lying to the world– and the US in the boldest way imaginable!

Comments are closed

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE

WHAT'S HOT

  1. Independent 2013 Survey Shows Veterans Highly Satisfied with VA Care
  2. Ed Miliband latest Western politician ‘taken in’ by Sderot
  3. Hurtling into DARKNESS: America’s Great Leap Towards Global Tyranny
  4. Alison Weir: Why is the US Honoring a Racist Rabbi?
  5. Promoting a “Right to Heal” from Ft. Hood to Abu Ghraib
  6. Tech Business Has Increased Need For Hiring!
  7. Excavation Company Looking To Hire Skilled Veterans!
  8. CIA Terror Chief Pulls Rank in Kiev
  9. VA Researchers Receive Nation’s Top Award for Early Career Scientists
  10. Understanding Modern Israel: Why It Is Driving The World Towards Madness
  11. President Vladimir Putin’s letter to leaders of European countries
  12. BBC misreports John Kerry on talks failure
  13. A review of the role of workplace mobbing at Fort Hood, TX
  14. Washington and NATO’s New Surrealpolitik
  15. Chris Hedges: “Israel’s War on American Universities”
  16. Iran, Orientalism, and Western Illusions about Syria
  17. HHS announces progress in disease prevention and health promotion
  18. InfoCision IS Hiring U. S. Veterans For Their Call Center Solutions
  19. Look at the World from Behind the Wall: Part Two
  20. VA Hosts Senior International Forum and Ministerial Summit on Veterans Affairs
  1. REXW: With all due respect to the comment above…” “As the U.S. military withdraws from Afghanistan,” it...
  2. Sean Steele: Jason more reason to dump those worthless parasites and declare Iran an allied nation. The world would...
  3. Sean Steele: This prophecy, by Benjamin Franklin, was made in a “CHIT CHAT AROUND THE TABLE DURING...
  4. jvmcdee: “…The 58-year-old spymaster is the embodiment of how Washington has itself become a secret,...
  5. Anonymous Nr: From an article by Janice Harper in 2011, about another incident of workplace violence:...

Apply for VA Home Loan Now!

Military Veterans Radio

Archives