JOIN VNN COLUMNIST TEAM | SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER
VETERANS NEWS NOW ON : FACEBOOK | TWITTER | FORUM
|

Hagel in the Dock: AIPAC Dog Bites Man

The doings in the US Senate over the nomination of former Senator Chuck Hagel to be Secretary of Defense are illustrative of many things, not all of which are what they seem to be at first glance. We have a few days now before this plays out, and therefore an opportunity to reflect on the dynamics at work here.

 

by Dr. Alan Sabrosky

 

REPRISE

I won’t bore everyone with a blow-by-blow recitation of what has happened to date. Suffice to say that Hagel’s nomination was controversial before it became a reality, in stark contrast to the near-unanimous acclaim that greeted the nomination of John Kerry to be the next Secretary of State — a difference that was reflected in their very different hearings, from Kerry’s gracious love-fest to Hagel’s vicious grilling, and in the votes in their respective committees and the full Senate.

What purportedly made Hagel controversial were his stands on three issues: (1) Israel, or at least its lobby; (2) Iraq, as in Israel’s latest national victim, courtesy of the US and its so-called “coalition of the willing”; and (3) Iran, as in the notional “existential threat” Israel has contrived, and which it hopes to make its next victim — as with Iraq, largely through the use of American military power, economic coercion and diplomatic leverage, alone or in concert with whatever others Washington can entice to join it.

What then ensued was a fascinating political ballet in which Hagel and his Administration backers tried to marshal as much support from Jewish organizations, correspondents and senators as possible, asserting that he was neither anti-Israel nor anti-Semitic.  His opponents – principally AIPAC (the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, Israel’s semi-official lobby in Washington), CUFI (Christians United for Israel, the mostly evangelical “Christian Zionist” step-child of AIPAC), and the assorted neo-conservative “chicken hawks” littering the journalistic and think-tank scene — equally strenuously tried to demonstrate the converse, with the “neo-cons” and CUFI taking more and more of the lead as time went on.

Oddly enough, what the rest of America may have thought about all this largely went unremarked, almost to the extent that one would have thought we had stepped back a few thousand years to a time when the ancient Near East (as it was once called) was the be-all and end-all of what passed for world politics in our part of the world. China? Russia? India? The so-called “war on terror”? The condition of the US military? Only piddly little things when weighed in the political balance against Israel, Israel, and Israel — the Washington counterpart of the realtor’s trinity of “location, location, and location.”

REFLECTIONS

Looking at the various comments Hagel made over the years, the positions he took, and his votes, it is difficult to see how he could have been construed by anyone to the left of the late and lamentable Meir Kahane as hostile to Israel as a country. He steadfastly supported it on virtually every issue. He continued to voice support for the moribund “two-state solution,” which has been a dead issue for at least the last 300,000 Jewish settlers, if not from the outset. Never did he suggest withholding aid  from Israel for its assorted transgressions, much less imposing sanctions on it, but endorsed an approach completely congruent with the positions of moderate-to-liberal pro-Israel Jewish groups such as the Israel Policy Forum (IPF).

His actual lapses were four: (1) he remarked that Israel treated Palestinians like caged animals — true, of course, but one of many unspeakable truths in Washington; (2) he referred to the leverage in Washington of the Jewish lobby, not simply the Israel lobby — also true, as manifested in the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations (check out its website), of which AIPAC is but one of forty-nine organizations under its umbrella, enhanced by shoals of smaller organizations and individuals; (3) he saw no reason to rush head-long into a war with Iran when there was no hard evidence at all that its actions or intentions posed a threat to anyone else — perfectly reasonable by any standard, and a position shared by the current US Joint Chiefs of Staff (JCS), among many others; and (4) he rejected AIPAC’s core principle on Capitol Hill, which is that US senators and representatives should always act as if they were Israeli senators and representatives on any and all matters of even the slightest interest to Israel, and refused to blindly endorse AIPAC’s episodic resolutions circulating on Capitol Hill.

 The first three lapses were venal sins, and might well have prompted little more than some ritualistic criticism from those who ended up arrayed against him, but the fourth was — to AIPAC and thus to its assorted confederates — a mortal sin, implying that he might stray, and stray far, from the AIPAC-defined political reservation that is its Washington enclave. This is not something AIPAC can tolerate, especially in so critical a position as Secretary of Defense, who in concert with the JCS could actually pose a hurdle to Israel’s ambitions. And it was this supposed failing — not actual hostility to Israel and its security, but to AIPAC and its heavy-handed tactics on Capitol Hill — that fueled opposition to Hagel, and the vitriolic attacks and interrogation he encountered (principally from Republicans) in the Senate, and from the neo-conservatives and CUFI more generally.

LOOKING AHEAD

Hagel was in a unique position to take on AIPAC: 12 years in the Senate, a combat veteran, a good position with the Atlantic Council, and a history of having made more candid comments about Israel and AIPAC than anyone else nominated to such a post for many years. If he had stood by what he had said in the past, he might not have been confirmed – hell, he might not be confirmed anyway! – but the entire issue would have been thrown onto the public screen, thanks to C-SPAN among others, and could have forced a degree of disclosure and open discussion on these issues heretofore unknown. Asked a pointed question, for instance, such as who is intimidated by AIPAC, he could have named names, and no one could have stopped him from doing so. Everyone in the committee room would have cringed, but at least some others elsewhere would have sat up and taken notice. From such small beginnings do great things happen.

But he threw away the chance, recanted everything, apologized for most of his remarks, denied knowing or consorting with people he had to have known well, and ended up asserting that Israel was our best ally in the entire world – God, how our NATO allies, plus South Korea, Australia and New Zealand, and others must have laughed — or cringed! It is so bad to see a grown man grovel for the sake of his ambition, and that is just what he did. Yet in fairness, it should not be laid entirely at his door: Had  John Kerry been subjected to a comparable eight-hour inquisition, he would not have come out well, either; those exercises could even have had Mother Teresa twisting in the wind.

The best that can be expected right now is a weakened, compromised but almost certainly vengeful Hagel confirmed as Secretary of Defense, with most of his former party arrayed against him. And most of his former Republican colleagues would have to understand that under Secretary Hagel, Pentagon contracts to their states are likely to be few and far between, or at least attributable to Democratic members in their states if they come at all. But Hagel’s options are limited. If he does attempt to renege on his mea maxima culpa, his experience before assorted committees in the Republican-dominated House of Representatives would make that in the Senate Armed Services Committee recently seem like a stroll through the Garden of Eden — pre-snake, of course!

The worst is his withdrawal rather than continuing to run the gauntlet of personal attacks, or holding fast yet being rejected for the position – something the neo-cons will assuredly try very hard to accomplish. And they may well do so: the pattern so far is to attack anyone critical of Israel or its supporters, then to extract an apology from them coupled with a retraction of whatever was seen to be offensive, and finally to destroy them anyway. This would put Hagel in the Faustian position of having bartered his ethical soul and his principles away for something snatched from his grasp in the end by a hydra-headed political Mephistopheles.

Whichever happens, we can be sure of one thing: no one with his prospects for achieving a senior cabinet position is likely to be presented for many years to come, if at all. There may not be a magic bullet to end the Zionist domination of the American political process, but in Chuck Hagel, we got a dud. I do not regret supporting him at the beginning, but I wish he had shown more fortitude as the process degenerated — admittedly a lot to ask, but then the position to which he was nominated cries out for someone like that, which it has not had for many years. Well, perhaps next time — if there is one — it’ll be a Marine in his place.

____________________________________________________________________________

*Alan Sabrosky (Ph.D, University of Michigan) is a ten-year US Marine Corps veteran and a graduate of the US Army War College. He can be contacted at docbrosk@comcast.net

Short URL: http://www.veteransnewsnow.com/?p=221638

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VNN or any other VNN authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors or partners and technicians. Notices

Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Austins School of Spa Technology
ME Online
slow aging
What Price Gold


Posted by on Feb 20 2013, With 0 Reads, Filed under AfPak, Africa, Editors' Picks, Expert Opinions ME, Heroes, Iraq War, Libya, Middle East Conflicts, Military, News From the Region, Of Interest, Support the Troops, War. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

COMMENTS

To post a comment, you must login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with our site and post your comment.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Legal Notice

Comments Closed

3 Comments for “Hagel in the Dock: AIPAC Dog Bites Man”

  1. Yes, indeed it is pathetic that the politicians and leaders of the only superpower are reduced to such servile boot-licking, by Israeli apologists in the Senate, shamelessly on display on national television for the whole world to witness.

    As I have said before and I reiterate, the Jewish Lobby has a very long history of threatening and blackmailing US politicians and even US presidents and subjecting critics of Israel in America, to the anti semitic smear.

    This is just one more example in a long list of decent Americans that have at least had the courage to try and lift the taboo but have ended up paying dearly for being forthright in their criticism of Israel.

    The Hagel nomination hearings has been a great exposure, whoever planned it and if it was in fact a plan, they have achieved their objectives.

    For how long are Americans expected to continue to censor themselves for Israel? Do they realize they are becoming the laughing stock of the free World? Think about how many otherwise honest, knowledgeable are restrained and have worn the same albatross around their necks.

    “The truth is, for our democracy to work it needs not just an engaged citizenry, but an informed one.”

    In a democracy, public misperceptions carry an enormous cost, eg: The Invasion of Iraq.

    As PC Roberts notes: “To every American’s shame, the Republicans demonstrated for all the world to see that they are wholly owned subsidiaries of the Israel Lobby.The Israel Lobby is not their only master. They are also owned by powerful interest groups, such as Wall Street and the Military/Security Complex.” dig a little deeper into Wall Street & Military Industrial Security Complex and you will once again be led to the tribe. Go figure!

  2. “The truth is, for our democracy to work it needs not just an engaged citizenry, but an informed one.”

    The citizenry doesn’t seem to be engaged or informed if we look at the procedure, content and relevance of the questions at the charade known as the Senate Confirmation Hearing into the appointment of Chuck Hagel as Defence Secretary.

    Do you think that such obvious ‘apologists for Israel’ as Lindsay Graham, John McCain and Ted Cruz attended the mandatory AIPAC pre-Senate hearing briefing where their scripts anmd instructions were prepared for their use?

    Yes, It was perhaps the most inane and painfully obvious example of a session with a hidden agenda. Fortunately, for those Americans who even know the hearing was in progress, this hidden agenda soon became blatantly obvious to all.

    Short term: delay the appointment to emphasize the power of the Zionist AIPAC, known as israel’s Fifth Column.

    Medium term: show the people of the US that AIPAC undoubtedly control the running of foreign affairs (and who is boss) ……and

    Long term: to make the task of President Obama and his administration (in the Middle East) impossible for the next three+ years.

    What was the real result of the performances?

    Optimistically, let us hope that even more of the voting public see what AIPAC is all about. Make a note of those loudest “Israeli Senators” voices, their agenda and their objectives, neither of which has any relevance to the good government of the USA.

    We need to urgently see a groundswell “Emergency Committee for America” working against media control by Israel via Zionist ownership, the removal of the PAC and SUPERPAC’s funding elections and a greater level of attention to those elected representatives who have a history of being corrupted. They need to be identified and unelected or booted out.

    An engaged citizenry in a democracy can do all this.

    That way we will see some benefit from the excruciating embarrassment over the past weeks in that unholy chamber, the House of Zion, better known as the US Senate

Comments are closed

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE

WHAT'S HOT

  1. Opportunities for Veterans Abound in Agriculture
  2. Fifty-One Thousand Troops Diagnosed with Brain Injury
  3. Cold War II: Interview with Nikolay Patrushev, Secretary of the Russian Security Council
  4. U.S. Leaders: “Listen to this Irish Senator”
  5. Philip Giraldi: Stopping Cyber Hate
  6. Brazil under CIA Pressure
  7. Soros and the CIA Now Banking on Neves to Defeat Rousseff
  8. Christian Evangelicals Increasingly Support Palestinian Human Rights
  9. How the Israel Lobby Set Beto O’Rourke Right
  10. Russia hunkers down vis-a-vis West
  11. Israel is losing its friends in the world
  12. The Neocons – Masters of Chaos
  13. Tables turned — Israel on the run
  14. Washington Admits: FSA Equals Fictitious Syrian Army
  15. Terror-scaremongering designed to erode freedoms, stamp out dissent
  16. World Order by Henry Kissinger
  17. Illan Pappe & Miko Peled on Zionist Israel
  18. Obama Knew Arming Rebels Was Useless, But Did It Anyway
  19. Agent Cameron still hasn’t got the message on Palestine
  20. West despotism behind Saudi death sentence
  1. Old Jules: Rufus – I’ve probably got more time than you do to spend doing this. I’m almost 71 years...
  2. paschn: The sooner the Christian/Muslim world rises up and tears off the Talmudic yoke of evil, contains or...
  3. Rufus Peterson: Suspicion was created at VT when you moved in over there and took up residence- out of nowhere,...
  4. DaveE: What a crock from that wretched Haaretz writer. Blame “The West” for the Jew problem. It’s...
  5. Old Jules: “Money and Law are the tools and the weapons of the Zionists, It is high time to engage them with...

Apply for VA Home Loan Now!

Military Veterans Radio

Archives