JOIN VNN COLUMNIST TEAM | SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER
VETERANS NEWS NOW ON : FACEBOOK | TWITTER | FORUM
|

Obama and the Israel lobby: Quo vadis?

Obama doesn’t have to run for re-election again but Congressional Dems do, and they’ll put the same pressure on him in 2014 that they did in 2010 if he tries to force Netanyahu to abandon his vision of “greater Israel.” The bottom line: No U.S. pressure on Israel, and thus no chance for a deal.

 

by Stephen M Walt

 

Congress — AIPAC Village!

 

Has lost its mojo? Does ’s reelection prove that the lobby is getting weaker, and that he can return to Middle East peacemaking with new confidence and resolve?

It’s no secret that has a frosty relationship with Israeli PM , fueling GOP hopes that Israel would be a wedge issue that would attract lots of Jewish voters and . At least one prominent hardline Zionist, , spent tens of millions of dollars trying to buy the election for Romney, and he got bupkis for all that cash. So now that Obama’s got a second term, will he blithely ignore AIPAC et al and pursue an even-handed approach to the Middle East peace process?

Don’t bet on it. For starters, the election didn’t show that the traditional “status quo lobby” was substantially weaker. Why? Because Obama caved to these groups a long time ago, and there was hardly any daylight between him and Romney on this issue. As the Obama campaign repeatedly emphasized, they had been extraordinarily supportive of Israel from Day One: providing increased levels of military aid, expanding various forms of security cooperation (including joint operations against Iran), and providing diplomatic cover in the United Nations and elsewhere. Obama dropped his early insistence on a settlement freeze and eventually gave up on the peace process. The only thing that Netanyahu didn’t get from Obama was a war against Iran, and plenty of top Israeli officials didn’t think that was a very good idea either. Given that there wasn’t much difference between Obama and Romney on Israel, therefore, American Jewry stuck with its long-standing liberal preferences and voted overwhelmingly for Obama and the Democrats.

But the election is over, and the second term beckons. Won’t Obama be tempted to secure a legacy as a peacemaker (remember that Nobel Prize?), and go back to his original vision of “two states for two peoples?” I don’t think so.

Conditions in the region aren’t propitious: Israel continues to drift rightward, Netanyahu is overwhelmingly likely to be reelected, and the tumult of the Arab spring is bound to make everyone more cautious (and with good reason). The Palestinian Authority is less and less popular, and even if he wanted to, Mahmoud Abbas could never persuade his followers to accept the one-sided arrangement that is Netanyahu’s idea of a “Palestinian state.” Obama doesn’t have to run for re-election again but Congressional Dems do, and they’ll put the same pressure on him in 2014 that they did in 2010 if he tries to force Netanyahu to abandon his vision of “greater Israel.” The bottom line: No U.S. pressure on Israel, and thus no chance for a deal.

If you’re Barack Obama, in short, this just doesn’t look like a smart place to invest a lot of time, effort, and political capital. Plus, my hunch is that he’s going to try to secure his legacy by “nation-building” here at home, not by pursuing the elusive grail of Middle East peace. For that matter, if he decides to spend any political capital in that part of the world, it will be on Iran, not Israel-. Meanwhile, Congress will reflexively vote the aid package and sign whatever goofy letters and resolutions that AIPAC dreams up. Politicians and policy wonks will continue to pay homage to the “special relationship,” lest they come under fire from the lobby and its various watchdogs and smear artists.

Which is not to say that nothing has changed, as argues here. Public discourse on this topic is more open than it used to be, some journalists have become largely immune to intimidation, and the role of the lobby in stifling peace efforts and promoting a military approach to Iran is now plain for all to see. J Street has been more equivocal than some of us might have hoped, but it can take some pride in helping escort Islamophobes from office and getting some pro-peace candidates elected. Writers like Peter Beinart have bravely spoken truth to those with closed minds and closed eyes, and even some stalwart defenders of Israel seem increasingly troubled by where it’s headed.

But I don’t see a sea-change; at least not yet. AIPAC and its allies don’t get everything they want, of course, but they can still put real limits on what the president and his advisors are willing to try. We still have not reached the point where politicians are willing to openly acknowledge that a normal relationship would be better for both countries than the current special relationship of unconditional U.S. support. You didn’t hear Obama, Romney, or any other major candidate say anything like that in 2012, which tells you that fear of the lobby remains a potent political force. That’s not good for us, but it’s even worse for Israelis and Palestinians. Which is why I’d be delighted if the next four years proves me wrong.


Stephen M. Walt is the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international affairs at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government, where he served as academic dean from 2002-2006. He previously taught at Princeton University and the University of Chicago, where he served as master of the social science collegiate division and deputy dean of social sciences. Professor Walt is the author of The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy (coauthor J.J. Mearsheimer).

Short URL: http://www.veteransnewsnow.com/?p=218663

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VNN or any other VNN authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors or partners and technicians. Notices

Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Austins School of Spa Technology
ME Online
slow aging
What Price Gold


Posted by on Nov 25 2012, With 0 Reads, Filed under Causes, Civil Liberties, Corruption, Cost to the US, Editors' Picks, Expert Viewpoints, Foreign Policy, Government, Israel Lobby in Action, Legislation, Life, Peace, Politico. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

COMMENTS

To post a comment, you must login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with our site and post your comment.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Legal Notice

Comments Closed

Comments are closed

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE

WHAT'S HOT

  1. The End of Evangelical Support for Israel? The Jewish State’s International Standing
  2. A Poison Pill for the Iran-Nuke Deal
  3. Center for Disease Control Seeks Veterans for Study
  4. US targets Syria infrastructure rather than militants: Sabrosky
  5. NWO Overman is the Eupraxsophy of Transhumanism
  6. US-led coalition against ISIL: Front for regime change
  7. AngloZionist Empire is at War with Russia
  8. Abbas To UN: “End This Settlement Occupation”
  9. Indo-China Two Steps Forward One Step Back (II)
  10. Australian false flag exposed or pure stupidity?
  11. ISIS and the USA: Expansion and Resistance by Decapitation
  12. Here Come the Kagans—Their War Plan to Defeat the Islamic State
  13. Coalition of the Clueless in Syria
  14. Defense Contractor Hiring Veterans Now
  15. Neocons Grow Frantic over Iran Progress
  16. Non-Aligned Media — Brandon Martinez & Joshua Blakeney
  17. Silicon Valley Corporatists
  18. ‘US seeks to target Syrian govt.’
  19. Dueling Ideologies: Lavrov v. Rasmussen
  20. Production Company Hiring Today!
  1. Debbie Menon: Saker is first rate! Excellent effort, thanks! Dear Readers, This is compulsory reading for all. Please...
  2. Niloufer Bhagwat: Kindly read the detailed and excellent analysis by Andre Vltchek in Information Clearing House...
  3. John Doe: I thought the prank pulled by Palestinia students putting the 24 Hour evacuate / slated for destruction...
  4. rhys: While it does seem to be a very serious error, this is Australia you’re talking about, the #1 nanny...
  5. Rufus Peterson: So this is the fresh tar baby the US feels impelled to throw itself into, while still ignoring the...

Apply for VA Home Loan Now!

Military Veterans Radio

Archives