JOIN VNN COLUMNIST TEAM | SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER
VETERANS NEWS NOW ON : FACEBOOK | TWITTER | FORUM
|

Court Rules Crooked Health Insurer Can’t Cut Vietnam War Veteran’s Disability

Sun life and health insurance company: Low-grade pond scum

Anti-veteran, anti-people Health Insurance company, Sun Life and Health Insurance Co., slapped down

 

Read the opinion at James Riley v. Sun Life and Health Insurance, 10-2850 (8th Cir. 2011); Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit

 

By Margery A. Beck

 

Omaha, Nebraska—A federal appeals court ruled in favor of a Vietnam veteran Friday, saying his long-term disability insurance carrier can’t reduce his monthly payment by the amount he gets from veterans’ benefits.

James Riley, 56, of Bellevue, left his job when symptoms multiple sclerosis made it impossible for him to work. Sun Life and Health Insurance Co., which provided the long-term disability plan for Riley’s employer, began paying Riley benefits in January 2005.

But two years later, Sun Life learned Riley also received veterans’ benefits for the disease that developed while he was serving in Vietnam War during the early 1970s. Sun Life reduced the amount it was paying Riley and claimed he owed nearly $21,000 in overpayments.

The company pointed to language in Riley’s policy that said monthly disability payments could be reduced by “other income,” which were defined in the plan as any amount of disability or retirement benefits under the U.S. Social Security Act, the Railroad Retirement Act or “any other similar act or law provided in any jurisdiction.”

Riley objected and eventually sued Sun Life. A federal court in Omaha ruled in favor of Sun Life last year, but a three-judge panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s decision Friday.

The appeals court said the Veterans Benefits Act is different from the Social Security and Railroad Retirement acts.

“The SSA and RRA disability benefits programs are both federal insurance programs based upon employment, and the amount of an award under their terms depends upon how much has been paid in,” the appeals panel said in its opinion. “Conversely, the VA benefits Riley is entitled to receive are not from an `insurance’ program, but instead are considered obligatory compensation for injuries to service men and women during military duty.”

Federal law says any veteran who develops multiple sclerosis within seven years from the time he or she served during war shall be presumed to have incurred or aggravated the disease during that service.

Judge Steven Colloton dissented, saying the appeals court ignored many of the similarities between the veterans and other programs, including that all three are run by the government and provide regular payments to qualified people who have suffered a physical disability without regard to fault.

“We obviously believe the dissenting decision by Judge Colloton correctly analyzed the issues,” said Philadelphia attorney Joshua Bachrach, who represented Sun Life.

Bachrach said he and his clients are considering asking the full 8th Circuit to review the case.

Nora Kane, Riley’s Omaha attorney, said she’s pleased with the ruling and happy for her client, whom she said has not received any disability payments from Sun Life since 2007 and has had to live off Social Security and veterans’ benefits.

“We think the 8th Circuit got it right,” Kane said. “I think it’s a good decision, not just for him, but I think for other vets, too. The calls I’ve gotten from lawyers around the country tell me that everybody’s not winning it.”

Short URL: http://www.veteransnewsnow.com/?p=136282

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VNN or any other VNN authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors or partners and technicians. Notices

Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Apply for your VA Home Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Get Your Loan Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Apply for Jobs on HireVeterans.com Now
Austins School of Spa Technology
Austins School of Spa Technology
slow aging
What Price Gold

Posted by on Oct 8 2011, With 0 Reads, Filed under Regional, Veterans, Veterans Affairs. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

COMMENTS

To post a comment, you must login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with our site and post your comment.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Legal Notice

Comments Closed

Comments are closed

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE

WHAT'S HOT

  1. CNN plummets to lowest ratings in 23 years
  2. Hospice Cat Brings Comfort To Veterans At The End Of Their Lives
  3. The Bush Institute Talks with General Pace and General Chiarelli about Post 9/11 Veterans
  4. The Berlin Wall Just Another Brick in The Wall
  5. On Veterans Day, You Can Help Crowdsource World War I Diaries
  6. Free dental work, meals and other deals for veterans on Veterans Day
  7. Obama Lame Duck in a NeoCon Congress
  8. Top Ten Movies to Watch on Veterans Day
  9. Adelson and Saban Try To Out-Hawk Each Other
  10. Veterans, Their Oath, Our Freedoms
  11. Another Fake Bin Laden Story — Paul Craig Roberts
  12. VA to host annual National Veterans Small Business Engagement
  13. Why is Veterans Day 2014 on Tuesday? Holiday history and more
  14. Community College Hiring
  15. Will the blackmail of British Jewish funders backfire?
  16. Republican victory and Iran N-talks
  17. Russia’s Vulnerability to EU – US Sanctions and Military Encroachments
  18. VetCap Surges During National Veterans Small Business Week
  19. GET OUT: Auburn Veterans Day Parade, antiques and collectibles show and more happenings
  20. Canada’s ‘Remembrance Day’: righteous or rancorous?
  1. Debbie Menon: Classic Don Nash!
  2. Don Nash: Well if it wasn’t for Barack Hussein Obama, the Berlin Wall would never have come down. No, really....
  3. DaveE: Believe me, those “delightful Americans” like me (I’m constantly being called...
  4. rexw: Obama in reality, has been a lame duck president after six months into his term as a compliant...
  5. rexw: The most relevant comment above is as follows… “It began Saturday night, when the first task Netanyahu...

Apply for VA Home Loan Now!

Military Veterans Radio

Archives